Diving Science

Closed-Circuit Oxygen Diving in the U.S. Navy

8 min read · 27 March 2026
Hero illustration for the article “Closed-Circuit Oxygen Diving in the U.S. Navy”

Updated: October 20, 2026

Frank K. Butler Jr’s review, “Closed-circuit oxygen diving in the U.S. Navy,” appeared in Undersea & Hyperbaric Medicine in 2004 (31(1):3–20; PMID 15233156). It concerns a specific form of military diving: a rebreather that recycles gas while using oxygen as its breathing gas. The physiological principles remain relevant, but this article is a summary of the publication, not current Navy operating guidance. Navy procedures and equipment can change; divers must follow the applicable edition of U.S. Navy Diving Manual and their command’s training and authorization requirements.

What does closed-circuit oxygen diving involve?

A closed-circuit rebreather returns exhaled gas to a breathing loop. A carbon-dioxide absorbent removes the diver’s CO₂, while oxygen is added to replace what the body consumes and to maintain the intended loop composition. Unlike open-circuit scuba, which vents exhaled gas into the water on each breath, a closed circuit can greatly reduce bubbles and conserve gas.

“Oxygen rebreather” is not interchangeable with “mixed-gas rebreather.” In a pure-oxygen circuit, the oxygen fraction is effectively 1.0; in a mixed-gas unit, the loop’s oxygen fraction is controlled or monitored as part of a different gas plan. That distinction determines depth limits. At 1 atmosphere absolute (ATA), pure oxygen has a partial pressure (PO₂) of 1 ATA; at 2 ATA it is 2 ATA. The diver’s depth, not just the cylinder label, sets the exposure.

Reduced bubbles can be useful for selected military tasks, but they do not make the equipment fail-safe or suitable for every mission. A closed loop depends on functioning valves, a gas supply, a correctly packed scrubber and competent monitoring; faults may not announce themselves with the obvious loss of bubbles or gas supply associated with some open-circuit problems.

Why does oxygen exposure matter?

Oxygen toxicity is linked to partial pressure and exposure time. At sea level, breathing air (about 21% oxygen) gives a PO₂ near 0.21 ATA. In contrast, at 6 metres of seawater (approximately 1.6 ATA), a pure-oxygen circuit would produce a PO₂ of approximately 1.6 ATA. This is why pure-oxygen diving is restricted to shallow depths under approved procedures; the calculation is a physiological illustration, not permission to dive to a particular depth.

Central nervous system (CNS) oxygen toxicity can cause visual or auditory changes, nausea, twitching, confusion or a seizure. A seizure underwater can lead to loss of the mouthpiece and drowning. Warning signs are not reliable in every diver, and a seizure may occur without a useful warning. Pulmonary oxygen toxicity is a different concern, generally associated with cumulative exposure over longer periods; symptoms can include chest discomfort, cough and reduced exercise tolerance.

Planning tools such as the U.S. Navy oxygen-exposure limits and the NOAA oxygen-exposure table address time as well as PO₂. These limits are operational risk-management tools, not sharp biological thresholds or guarantees against injury. They should not be used to extend a Navy dive beyond its approved depth, duration or procedure.

What technical and physiological factors require attention?

Carbon-dioxide control is as important as oxygen delivery. If the scrubber is exhausted, incorrectly assembled, exposed to water or used outside its approved duration and conditions, CO₂ can rise in the loop. Hypercapnia may cause headache, breathlessness, impaired judgement and loss of consciousness; increased CO₂ can also intensify susceptibility to CNS oxygen toxicity. A diver who feels unwell must not assume the cause is simply exertion or anxiety.

Before a dive, trained personnel verify the specific apparatus and approved checklist, including breathing-loop integrity, valves, oxygen supply and scrubber installation. During the dive, workload, cold, depth and breathing resistance can affect both gas exchange and the diver’s ability to identify a developing fault. A closed-circuit system therefore requires equipment-specific training, a suitable bailout plan and a team prepared to respond—not merely a functioning oxygen cylinder.

  • PO₂ and depth: calculate exposure using absolute pressure and the actual breathing-gas fraction; do not infer safety from oxygen percentage alone.
  • Scrubber condition: use the approved absorbent and replacement interval for the unit and conditions; never treat a generic duration as universal.
  • Monitoring and alarms: understand the apparatus’s indicators and failure responses before entering the water.
  • Workload and health: exertion, illness, cold and individual variation can change risk and performance.
  • Emergency readiness: follow the unit’s bailout, buddy and rescue procedures, rather than improvising a response underwater.
Breathing-system comparison: operating principles, not a dive plan or a substitute for equipment-specific training.
Feature Open-circuit scuba Closed-circuit oxygen rebreather
Exhaled gas Released into the water Returned to the breathing loop
Carbon dioxide Exhaled gas is vented Removed by a scrubber
Gas supply Gas is used on each breath Oxygen is added as it is consumed
Key oxygen constraint Depends on the breathing mix and depth Pure oxygen’s PO₂ rises directly with ambient pressure
Characteristic operational concern Gas consumption and bubbles Loop, scrubber and oxygen-control failures may be less obvious

Why is the subject important in naval and scientific diving?

The Navy’s interest in oxygen rebreathers is tied to missions where bubbles can compromise concealment and where gas conservation matters. These benefits come with an unusually direct coupling between depth and PO₂ when the loop contains pure oxygen. Naval employment therefore depends on mission-specific authorization, equipment qualification and disciplined depth control—not on a general claim that closed circuit is superior to open circuit.

For diving medicine, the topic illustrates why symptoms, gas exposure and apparatus history must be considered together. A post-dive assessment may need to distinguish CNS oxygen toxicity, pulmonary effects, hypercapnia and other diving injuries. Scientific divers should likewise match apparatus and procedures to the research task and the relevant institutional safety system. The 2004 review provides historical and technical context; current conduct must be governed by current Navy instructions and qualified medical advice.

  • 2004 publication year of Butler Jr’s review
  • 31(1):3–20 journal volume, issue and pages
  • PMID 15233156 PubMed identifier for the cited article
  • 1.0 oxygen fraction for a pure-oxygen circuit; PO₂ still rises with ambient pressure

Frequently asked questions

How does closed-circuit differ from open-circuit diving?

Open-circuit scuba vents exhaled gas into the water. A closed-circuit unit recycles gas, removes CO₂ in a scrubber and adds oxygen. The exact gas-control method varies by rebreather, so training on one unit does not qualify a diver to use another.

Why can oxygen become hazardous underwater?

Water pressure increases ambient pressure and therefore the PO₂ of a given gas mixture. For pure oxygen, PO₂ is about 1 ATA at the surface and rises with depth; excessive exposure can cause CNS toxicity, including seizure, while prolonged exposure can affect the lungs.

What should a diver do about medical concerns after a dive?

Stop diving and seek urgent medical assessment for a seizure, confusion, breathing difficulty, chest symptoms or other significant post-dive illness. Tell clinicians the dive depth and duration, breathing apparatus and gas, symptom timing, and any suspected scrubber or loop fault. For a suspected diving emergency, use local emergency services and the established diving-emergency response; do not delay care while trying to diagnose oxygen toxicity yourself.

Citation details

  • Title: Closed-circuit oxygen diving in the U.S. Navy
  • Author: Butler Jr, FK
  • Year: 2004
  • Journal: Undersea & Hyperbaric Medicine, Spring 2004; 31(1):3–20
  • Identifier: PMID 15233156
  • Repository record: Rubicon Research Repository, handle 123456789/3986

This page is an original editorial summary of the publication’s bibliographic record and subject. It does not reproduce the paper or report its methods and findings in detail. Consult the cited article for the review’s full discussion and the current U.S. Navy Diving Manual and command procedures for operational requirements.

Related reading on Rubicon

  • The physiology behind oxygen toxicity in deep dives
  • Understanding oxygen toxicity risks and prevention in diving
  • Clarifying oxygen-toxicity limits in diving
  • Open-circuit versus closed-circuit rebreathers
  • CNS oxygen toxicity in closed-circuit diving
  • Screening for oxygen intolerance in Navy divers
  • More on diving science
  • Browse the research library